I would chose by cuteness. Although I don't know your friends' likes.
Here's my rankinghttp://www.stuffedsafari.com/Plush-Barn ... k-2645.htm
Very small and only a finger puppet. Does she have plush animals in her bed? Do you know about this even? Just in case you happen to know these things this might be to small but damn it this guy is so cute HAHA.http://www.stuffedsafari.com/Stuffed-Sn ... 760osn.htm
This guy is pretty cool too. A little too fury maybe though. http://www.stuffedsafari.com/Lifelike-1 ... 050094.htm
Cool because of size.
Oh and the honorable mention but probably nothing your friend would fancy: Mr. weird angry owl. This one cracked me up the moment I had klicked on your link.http://www.stuffedsafari.com/Plush-Grea ... -82565.htm